Mobile Menu - OpenMobile Menu - Closed


Twitter icon
Facebook icon
Flickr icon
Instagram icon

Democratic Veterans in Congress Decry Trump Administration’s VA-Tricare Merger Proposal

December 5, 2017
Press Release
In letter to Secretary Schulkin, Reps. criticize scheme as a “misguided step in the direction of privatization”

WASHINGTON DC – Today, 5 veterans serving in Congress – Reps. Ruben Gallego (D-AZ), Salud Carbajal (D-CA), Anthony Brown (D-MD), Ted Lieu (D-CA) and Collin Peterson (D-MN) – wrote to Department of Veterans Affairs Secretary David Shulkin urging him to reconsider a plan reportedly being developed behind closed doors to partially merge the VA and DOD health care systems.  The letter argues that the proposal represents a dangerous step towards privatization and could compromise the VA’s critical role as a direct provider of care to veterans.  The Congressmen also criticized the secretive manner in which the proposal is being developed—without public meetings, independent studies or consultations with veterans organizations.   

“Veterans recognize that merging the VA with Tricare simply doesn’t make sense,” said Rep. Gallego, a Marine Corps combat veteran.  “The Trump Administration’s obvious intention is to erode the VA’s ability to serve as a direct provider of care to men and women who risked their lives for our country.  This half-baked idea is also clearly consistent with the extreme privatization agenda that conservative groups have been pushing for years—groups more interested in discrediting government than in improving health care for our veterans.  Congress should put a stop to this unwise and unworkable plan.”    

The full text of the letter is below and can be found online here.      


Dear Secretary Shulkin:

We write to express our grave concerns regarding a proposal reportedly being considered by the Administration to partially merge the Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) and Department of Defense (DOD) health care systems. If adopted, this radical shift in policy could undermine care for veterans, increase their medical costs and dramatically expand the federal government’s reliance on the private sector to meet the unique needs of men and women who served our nation in uniform.  We strongly urge you to reconsider this proposal and to refrain from taking any additional steps to implement it without first consulting with key stakeholders, including interested Members of Congress and veterans groups. 

While we strongly support ongoing efforts to strengthen coordination between VA and DOD, it is important to note that the two Departments serve separate patient populations with drastically different needs.  Specifically, Tricare beneficiaries are generally younger and healthier than veterans who receive care through the VA. As stakeholders will attest, providers at the VA are uniquely trained and equipped to manage the care of a patient population that suffers from combat-related injury and illness, including traumatic brain injury and PTSD, in a culturally competent environment. We are therefore concerned that merging the two programs would compromise critical services for older veterans and those with serious medical conditions.  Further, a Tricare-VA merger could compel veterans entitled to care provided by the VA system to instead seek care through the private sector, a shift that could unfairly force veterans to pay out-of-pocket costs that they wouldn’t otherwise be required to bear.     

In addition to the potentially harmful impacts of this proposal, we are deeply concerned by the manner in which such a consequential change in veterans policy is being considered.  No public meetings or hearings have been held.  No independent studies have been conducted to estimate the cost of such a merger or to assess its implications for quality of care.  Moreover, national veterans service organizations, which collectively represent the interests of tens of millions of American veterans, have not been asked to provide input or recommendations as part of the decision-making process.  In fact, our best information about the substance of your proposal has come to light only as a result of media reporting on closed door deliberations within the Administration.  That’s certainly not the way that policy changes affecting millions of veterans should be considered. 

Finally, as strong supporters of high quality veterans’ health care and as advocates for the VA’s role as a direct provider of care to veterans, we believe this proposal represents a misguided step in the direction of privatization.  Again, given its potential consequences for our veterans and for the integrity of the VA health care system, we request that you reconsider your support for this merger and urge you to fully and transparently engage with key stakeholders, including Congress and veterans organizations, on this issue moving forwards.